Best Pizza in
California

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across California to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
71.0
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
San Francisco
highest avg. score in California
Verified Deliveries
746
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
35
San Francisco · San Diego · San Rafael · Madera · San Clemente · Palo Alto · Camarillo · Rocklin · Apple Valley · Upland · Pleasanton · Manteca · Tracy · South Gate · Chico · Norwalk · Rialto · Santa Maria · Simi Valley · Concord · Huntington Beach · Modesto · Santa Clarita · Fremont · Irvine · Stockton · Riverside · Anaheim · Bakersfield · Oakland · Long Beach · Sacramento · Fresno · San Jose · Los Angeles

State Hall of Fame

Tony's Pizza Napoletana
State Elite
1
Tony's Pizza Napoletana
95.00
Score
1570 Stockton St, San Francisco, CA 94133, USA

The Margherita pizza crust offers a controlled char, its airy chew yielding to San Marzano tomatoes and fresh mozzarella. The New Yorker, a different composition, maintains a crisp base beneath generous toppings of sausage, pepperoni, and ricotta, delivering concentrated flavor.

Service staff are welcoming and friendly, though attentiveness can falter during peak times. The energetic evening atmosphere, marked by neon lights and a lively dining room, contrasts with daytime observations of pizzaiolos at work near massive wood-fired ovens. Parking in the area presents challenges.

The Garlic Bread provides a notably crunchy, flavorful start. While the restaurant can accommodate large groups, some dishes, like the Spaghetti and Meatballs, have been described as bland and requiring enhancement.

Gibroni's Pizza
State Elite
2
Gibroni's Pizza
94.60
Score
555 N El Camino Real Ste e, San Clemente, CA 92672, USA

Gibroni's offers a deep-dish pizza reminiscent of classic Sicilian styles, its crust a notable feature. The 'Fun Guys' pizza stands out, its toppings providing a strong, memorable flavor profile. Wings, specifically the garlic parmesan, also received positive attention.

The environment at Gibroni's is boisterous, with patrons gathering to watch sports, children engaged with arcade games, and dogs present. Seating is available both inside and out, though the rear bar area tends toward loud. Ordering is done at the counter, with food brought to tables.

Despite some reports of excessive salt and an overabundance of bread in certain pizzas, the establishment’s popularity persists. The pizzas, when prepared correctly, are a primary draw.

Piccolo Italia
State Elite
3
Piccolo Italia
94.25
Score
799 O'Farrell St, San Francisco, CA 94109, USA

Piccolo Italia occupies a street-level space at 799 O'Farrell Street. The chicken fillet sandwich presents a surprising heft, with half proving sufficient for a single diner. Meat pizzas stand out, a decided advantage over the chicken offering.

The establishment operates with extended hours, a useful option for late-night meals. Staff members are noted for their welcoming demeanor, with Mr. Mukhtar himself contributing to the hospitable atmosphere.

The pesto base on a requested pizza offered notable flavor, complemented by a generous amount of vegetable toppings. A specific request for reduced cheese was met precisely.

The Pizza Shop
State Elite
4
The Pizza Shop
93.59
Score
3104 24th St, San Francisco, CA 94110, USA

The Pizza Shop offers generously sized, thin slices that arrive hot from the oven. A pepperoni slice, priced under five dollars, fulfills a specific craving for classic indulgence. The Cherry Pepper and Pesto, along with the White Mushroom topped with dollops of ricotta, stand out for their distinct flavor profiles.

The staff operates with notable speed and a considerate demeanor. Customers often find themselves ordering a second slice due to the satisfying nature of the pizza. The space itself is clean and provides a comfortable atmosphere for patrons.

A stop at The Pizza Shop proves to be an efficient and gratifying experience. The quick service and the satisfying texture of the pizza make it a notable option for a casual meal.

Presto Pasta
State Elite
5
Presto Pasta
93.16
Score
1701 E Daily Dr #6269, Camarillo, CA 93010, USA

Presto Pasta presents an array of pasta dishes prepared to order. The Marinara Cream with Angel Hair, Italian Sausage, and Parmesan offers a familiar comfort. The Cajun Shrimp Penne provides a richer flavor profile, and the accompanying garlic bread maintains a consistent texture of soft interior and crisp exterior.

Service personnel like Kayshaun contribute to the dining experience through attentive table checks and menu guidance. The restaurant's interior features a clean, comfortable atmosphere, with notable seasonal decorations evident during a recent visit. The establishment accommodates larger parties, a detail appreciated by diners requiring space for significant groups.

The tomato soup is notably well-received, as is the substantial spring salad with a distinctive blue cheese dressing. Meatballs are prepared to a tender consistency, complementing the tomato-based pasta preparations. The establishment offers a lunch special that proves to be a value.

City Directory