HomeOhio

Best Pizza in
Ohio

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Ohio to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
70.1
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Toledo
highest avg. score in Ohio
Verified Deliveries
144
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
6
Hamilton · Akron · Toledo · Cincinnati · Cleveland · Columbus

State Hall of Fame

Richards Pizza
State Elite
1
Richards Pizza
89.00
Score
417 Main St, Hamilton, OH 45013, USA

Richard's Pizza operates from a space on Main Street that retains a vintage ambiance, complete with a gas fireplace centrally positioned in the dining area. The establishment offers a familiar menu that includes pasta, salads, and a noted steak sandwich.

The steak sandwich is a frequent draw, a robust preparation of beef. Pizza at Richard's features a sauce that avoids overt sweetness and a crust with a distinct crispness. The cheese on the pizza achieves a well-browned, bubbly texture.

Service experiences at Richard's vary. Attentive staff members have been recognized for their kindness and efficiency. However, isolated reports detail instances of dismissive interactions from counter staff.

Giordano's
State Elite
2
Giordano's
88.00
Score
2137 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH 43240, USA

Giordano's presents a substantial deep-dish pizza. The crust, notably thick, provides a sturdy base for the generous layers of cheese. Toppings, such as sausage and mushrooms, are distributed evenly across the pie. A characteristic cheese pull, a visual cue for a certain style of pizza, is a predictable outcome with each slice.

The restaurant's interior accommodates diners even during inclement weather, where attentive servers manage the floor. Starters like Parmesan garlic fries and Caesar salad precede the main event. The portions are considerable; a single slice proves satiating.

While the deep-dish pizza garners attention, the spaghetti preparation presents a departure. The sauce, described as marinara, offered a thinner consistency. When questioned, the response indicated this was the standard offering, with Bolognese as an alternative.

decheco’s pizzeria
State Elite
3
decheco’s pizzeria
85.11
Score
1581 S Canton Rd, Akron, OH 44312, USA

DeCheco's Pizzeria presents a compact menu where the crust stands out. It achieves a pillowy interior with a yielding exterior crispness, providing a solid foundation for its toppings. The Nathan sauce offers a pleasant sweetness.

The restaurant's gluten-free offering is a notable success; it is indistinguishable from traditional crust, satisfying a common dietary requirement without compromise. Loaded jojos, a generous portion, prove unexpectedly compelling, their preparation a pleasant discovery.

The establishment maintains consistency and reliability across its pizza selections. The Cheese Lovers pizza is a direct fulfillment of a specific craving.

Pizza Cat
State Elite
4
Pizza Cat
85.00
Score
4034 Monroe St, Toledo, OH 43606, USA

The Smelly Cat pizza features a garlic base and roasted garlic, presenting a distinctive aromatic profile. Variations include the spicy Reuben with sauerkraut and a seafood option on gluten-free crust. Customizations extend to cauliflower and chicken crusts, with ingredients prepared to order.

Some pizzas struggle with a lack of assertiveness in their sauce and overall flavor. While crusts maintain integrity, the balance of toppings does not always achieve full potential. The establishment has also encountered significant delays in order fulfillment.

Despite occasional shortcomings, the culinary approach offers creative and bold flavor combinations. The thin, crispy crust provides a satisfying textural element.

Home Slice Pizza
State Elite
5
Home Slice Pizza
85.00
Score
28 S St Clair St, Toledo, OH 43604, USA

Home Slice Pizza offers a thin crust, crisp and without excessive sauce. Toppings are plentiful and cooked to a deep brown. The Italian salad provides a substantial portion, easily serving multiple diners.

The establishment features a cozy bar and dining area. Its beer selection is notable. Service proves prompt, with pizzas arriving quickly from the kitchen.

The mashed potato pizza is a distinctive offering, combining cream cheese and barbecue sauce with a five-cheese blend and hot sauce. This combination is notably addictive.

City Directory