Best Pizza in
Nebraska

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Nebraska to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
76.8
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Omaha
highest avg. score in Nebraska
Verified Deliveries
40
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
2
Lincoln · Omaha

State Hall of Fame

Mangia Italiana
State Elite
1
Mangia Italiana
87.00
Score
6516 Irvington Rd, Omaha, NE 68122, USA

Mangia Italiana’s cheese bread arrives as three substantial slices, offering a garlicky and cheesy preamble. The spaghetti sugo, a sweeter rendition of the classic, showcases a rich, yielding sauce. For those seeking alternatives, the gluten-free pizza crust garners specific praise for its structural integrity, and the cheese tortellini with shrimp delivers a notable Alfredo.

The interior presents a utilitarian atmosphere, allowing the food to take precedence. Service, characterized by a quick turn-around and knowledgeable staff, facilitates a streamlined dining experience. Notable is the availability of single, plain meatballs, a thoughtful inclusion for younger diners.

The Italian Deli salad provides a refreshing counterpoint to the richer pasta dishes. For those with dietary restrictions, the careful preparation of gluten-free items stands out, preventing cross-contamination and ensuring a positive outcome.

Williamsburg Pizza
State Elite
2
Williamsburg Pizza
86.99
Score
16869 Audrey St, Omaha, NE 68136, USA

The Cup & Char Grandma pie at Williamsburg Pizza presents a layered experience. Its crisp, chewy crust supports a balanced distribution of sauce and toppings. The garlic knots, notable for their shape, also warrant attention.

The establishment offers distinct differences between its square Grandma slices and the Brooklyn round pies. Experiencing both in succession reveals the nuances of the cheeses on the round pie against the tomato sauce of the Grandma. Meatballs, best consumed fresh, are also available.

The salty grain dusting on the bottom of the crust, a point of personal contention for one diner, did not detract from an otherwise positive assessment. This specific element can be omitted upon request, and the overall quality ensures a return visit.

Brick Oven Pizzeria
State Elite
3
Brick Oven Pizzeria
85.00
Score
624 S 72nd St, Omaha, NE 68114, USA

Brick Oven Pizzeria offers pizzas with crusts that achieve a satisfying crunch without being burnt, supporting a flavorful base for toppings. The hand-tossed variety delivers a notable chew, while the thin crust option provides a crisp texture. Fresh vegetables are present, and the pepperoni on one particular order was well-executed.

The kitchen produces made-to-order slices, a welcome approach for patrons seeking immediate consumption. Beyond pizza, cinnamon sticks are a distinctive offering, proving exceptionally popular. The availability of both marinara and ranch for dipping calzones adds another layer to the dining experience.

The establishment provides a casual atmosphere, with a dining area situated around a corner from the ordering counter. Staff are described as friendly, working late into the evening. The pizzas are substantial in size, capable of feeding multiple people over several days.

Smokin' Oak Wood-Fired Pizza and Taproom
State Elite
4
Smokin' Oak Wood-Fired Pizza and Taproom
84.63
Score
220 S 31st Ave #3103, Omaha, NE 68131, USA

Smokin' Oak's wood-fired pizzas arrive with a blistered crust, a characteristic of the high-temperature cooking. The buffalo chicken pizza, specifically, presented a noteworthy combination of heat and savory notes. Food emerged with notable speed, irrespective of the order size or complexity, as evidenced during event services.

Mary Beth provided a notable point of contact, managing large parties with a focus on guest experience. She handled scheduling, food presentation, and even drink budget oversight for events, facilitating a smooth flow for larger gatherings. The taproom’s self-serve system was a draw for guests, allowing for immediate access to beverages.

The atmosphere at Smokin' Oak is enhanced by live music and fireplace seating, creating a comfortable setting. Food is delivered to tables, a service beyond typical counter ordering, bridging the gap between casual and sit-down dining.

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe
State Elite
5
Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe
84.00
Score
1503 Farnam St, Omaha, NE 68102, USA

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe offers a counter-service experience where sandwiches can arrive with minimal ingredients, an observation noted in rushed preparations. The pizza, however, has been described as delicious, with a sauce and toppings that complement a soft crust.

The establishment faced customer service issues regarding delivery. One patron reported an inability to resolve an incorrect order, involving miscommunication with a driver and subsequent unhelpful interactions with store staff. The resolution process for a refund was protracted, requiring multiple calls over several days.

The cafe provides a selection of soups and beverages, with the lemonade-style drinks drawing particular attention. A detail noted was the provision of a small piece of bread for dipping in soup.

City Directory