Best Pizza in
Alabama

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Alabama to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
71.6
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Birmingham
highest avg. score in Alabama
Verified Deliveries
80
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
4
Mobile · Montgomery · Birmingham · Huntsville

State Hall of Fame

Fatso's Famous Pizza- Huntsville, AL
State Elite
1
Fatso's Famous Pizza- Huntsville, AL
94.21
Score
7914 Memorial Pkwy SW Suite B4, Huntsville, AL 35802, USA

Fatso's Famous Pizza offers a thin crust pizza featuring the sweet and zesty chicken. The balance of savory and sweet elements on this pie provides a distinct flavor profile.

The owner, a key figure in the operation, actively engages with patrons. He provides menu guidance and addresses inquiries with detail, contributing to the establishment's direct customer interaction.

The thin crust, as experienced with the sweet and zesty chicken pizza, arrived perfectly cooked. This preparation method allowed the toppings' flavors to command attention.

Rudy's Pizza Napoletana - Brindleyplace
State Elite
2
Rudy's Pizza Napoletana - Brindleyplace
88.00
Score
6 Oozells Sq, Brindley Pl, Birmingham B1 2JB, UK

Rudy's Pizza Napoletana in Brindleyplace offers a singular focus on Neapolitan-style pizza. The crust, characterised by its soft, thin centre and crisp edge, provides a well-textured foundation for toppings. Particular attention is paid to specific flavour profiles, such as the Diavola, described as a well-executed balance of heat and flavour.

The service at Rudy's is notably attentive. Staff readily accommodate patrons, including families with young children, evidenced by a creative approach to customisation. This element of thoughtful engagement contributes to a positive dining experience.

However, the acoustics of the space present a significant challenge. Noise reverberates readily, making conversation difficult even when the restaurant is not at capacity. This pervasive din detracts from an otherwise well-executed operation.

Pizza Pilgrims
State Elite
3
Pizza Pilgrims
87.71
Score
Stephenson Pl, Birmingham B2 4BQ, UK

The sourdough base, while possessing a pleasant chew, leaned towards the overly robust in texture. However, the mozzarella balls offered a compelling counterpoint, their creaminess a particular success. The guest pizza provided a well-executed flavour profile, a standout in its offering.

Service staff, specifically Leo, Danny, Anna, and Antonio, made a notable contribution to the dining experience. Their attentive recommendations and relaxed demeanour created a welcoming atmosphere from the outset. The concluding Nutella ring proved a decadent finish.

The "All I Want for Christmas Is Ragu" pizza featured a rich, slow-cooked ragu and a satisfying crust. Accompanied by a soft, garlicky flatbread, it presented a well-rounded offering.

Grimaldi's
State Elite
4
Grimaldi's
87.00
Score
2724 Carl T Jones Dr SE, Huntsville, AL 35802, USA

The char from the coal-fired brick oven imparts a distinct character to Grimaldi’s pizzas. A calzone, filled with meatballs and Italian sausage, offered a dense, savory counterpoint. The thin crust, with its slightly chewy texture, provided a foundation for bright tomato sauce.

Service was efficient, even amid a busy atmosphere, with staff navigating the space with purpose. Waitstaff provided helpful guidance through the menu, ensuring prompt delivery of orders. The atmosphere buzzed with activity, maintaining a steady rhythm throughout the evening.

Mozzarella arrived fresh, contributing a creamy richness to the pies. A chocolate-dipped cannoli concluded the meal, a sweet, crisp finish. The singular flavor of the sauce stood out, complementing the other components of the pizza.

Rudy's Pizza Napoletana - Bennetts Hill (Birmingham)
State Elite
5
Rudy's Pizza Napoletana - Bennetts Hill (Birmingham)
86.00
Score
9-10 Bennetts Hill, Birmingham B2 5RS, UK

Rudy's on Bennetts Hill presents a compelling case for Neapolitan pizza. The dough, blistered and airy from the intense heat of the oven, provides a chewy foundation for carefully selected toppings. A porchetta pizza arrived with a surprising yet balanced combination of flavours, while the addition of broccoli on a vegetarian option proved a well-received element.

The atmosphere buzzes with an energetic hum, the dining room filled with patrons clearly enjoying themselves. Servers navigate the busy space with efficiency and a welcoming demeanour; one patron noted their server, Matt, was particularly attentive when discussing dietary options. The tiramisu, a dessert often included in praise, is consistently mentioned as a standout.

Despite the constant influx of guests, the kitchen maintains a swift pace, with orders arriving promptly. The restaurant's layout accommodates a substantial number of diners, contributing to its lively character.

City Directory