Best Pizza in
New Mexico

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across New Mexico to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
77.7
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Albuquerque
highest avg. score in New Mexico
Verified Deliveries
40
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
2
Las Cruces · Albuquerque

State Hall of Fame

Slice and Dice Pizzeria
State Elite
1
Slice and Dice Pizzeria
89.90
Score
2225 Wyoming Blvd NE Suite C, Albuquerque, NM 87112, USA

Slice and Dice Pizzeria occupies 2225 Wyoming Blvd NE, Suite C, in Albuquerque. The establishment offers a diverse selection of board games, available for patrons to borrow or bring from home. Among the menu items, the pizza of the month often highlights unique flavor combinations.

The pizza itself arrives with a thin crust, its toppings thoughtfully distributed. Jalapeno poppers are also available. Vegan, gluten-free, and dairy-free options are prepared. Hand wipes are provided on tables.

During busy periods, the staff may appear stretched. However, individual employees are generally friendly and responsive to inquiries.

Mario's Pizza & Ristorante San Pedro & Uptown
State Elite
2
Mario's Pizza & Ristorante San Pedro & Uptown
89.00
Score
2401 San Pedro Dr NE, Albuquerque, NM 87110, USA

The spaghetti con albóndigas, served with soup and bread, stands as a noteworthy selection. Will, the server, provided friendly and professional attention.

Despite the busy atmosphere, Mauricio attended to patrons with politeness and focus. The establishment offers a range of Italian dishes.

One order of southwest chicken pasta arrived without chicken, containing only noodles and sauce. This oversight was noted with significant dissatisfaction.

Richie B's Pizza, Subs & Salads
State Elite
3
Richie B's Pizza, Subs & Salads
87.71
Score
2220 Unser Blvd NW ste b, Albuquerque, NM 87120, USA

The establishment offers an oversized pepperoni and green chile slice, substantial enough to require division before consumption. Its crust presents a pleasant crispness, complemented by the heat of the chile and a sweet, spicy honey drizzle.

A tamale stuffed pizza, specifically the green chile chicken variety, stands out. This creation integrates the earthiness of the tamale with the distinct flavor of green chile, enhanced by a complementary dip.

The restaurant maintains a clean environment, and its staff interacts with patrons amiably. While the Monster slice warrants attention, arriving before peak periods is advisable for an optimal visit.

Mikeys Pizza - Northeast Heights
State Elite
4
Mikeys Pizza - Northeast Heights
86.82
Score
3600 Cutler Ave NE #3, Albuquerque, NM 87110, USA

Mikey's Pizza presents a straightforward approach to pies. The truffle pizza, for instance, offers a distinct earthy profile. Slices here are notably large.

Ray provided attentive service, demonstrating a friendly and efficient demeanor. The crust achieved a satisfactory crispness. The establishment maintained a clean environment.

Pricing remains accessible, particularly for larger groups. Mikey himself engaged with guests, offering complimentary pizza and a positive attitude.

Dion's Pizza
State Elite
5
Dion's Pizza
86.00
Score
1060 El Paseo Rd, Las Cruces, NM 88001, USA

Dion’s Pizza offers a menu centered on pizza and sandwiches. The establishment at 1060 El Paseo Road in Las Cruces presents a clean dining environment. Lunchtime crowds are notably absent after 3 PM, facilitating swift order preparation by kitchen staff.

The pizzas here aim for a familiar taste, with some patrons finding them to be among the best in Las Cruces. Sandwiches also receive positive attention, with a notable mention of the green chile ranch. A particular sandwich preparation was described as efficient and skillfully handled by the counter staff.

An eighty's and nineties aesthetic contributes to the restaurant's ambiance. While the pizza was described as adequate by one diner, another found it comparable to New York style. The prices are noted as reasonable.

City Directory